Can Christian Scientists go to the Doctor

A Historical View

Mary Baker Eddy taught that relying on medical care for healing indicated a lack of faith in God and a misunderstanding of the healing power of Christian Science. Typically, Christian Scientists believe you can either pray for healing or seek medical care but not both. Eddy explains,

“Sickness is part of the error which Truth casts out. Error will not expel error. Christian Science is the law of Truth, which heals the sick on the basis of the one Mind or God. It can heal in no other way, since the human, mortal mind so-called is not a healer, but causes the belief in disease. Then comes the question, how do drugs, hygiene, and animal magnetism heal? It may be affirmed that they do not heal, but only relieve suffering temporarily, exchanging one disease for another. We classify disease as error, which nothing but Truth or Mind can heal, and this Mind must be divine, not human. Mind transcends all other power, and will ultimately supersede all other means in healing. In order to heal by Science, you must not be ignorant of the moral and spiritual demands of Science nor disobey them. Moral ignorance or sin affects our demonstration, and hinders its approach to the standard in Christian Science.

After the author’s sacred discovery, she affixed the name “Science” to Christianity, the name “error” to corporeal sense, and the name “substance” to Mind. Science has called the world to battle over this issue and its demonstration, which heals the sick, destroys error, and reveals the universal harmony. To those natural Christian Scientists, the ancient worthies, and to Christ Jesus, God certainly revealed the spirit of Christian Science, if not the absolute letter.” (S&H 482-484)

When Christian Scientists are unable to demonstrate Truth themselves, they may call a Christian Science practitioner, or Christian Science healer. What’s a Christian Science practitioner?

Mary Baker Eddy says this about accessing medical help:

If patients fail to experience the healing power of Christian Science, and think they can be benefited by certain ordinary physical methods of medical treatment, then the Mind physician [by which she means a Christian Science practitioner] should give up such cases, and leave invalids free to resort to whatever other systems they fancy will afford relief.” (Science and Health, page 443)

In Practice Today

In the early days of Christian Science, most adherents practiced “radical reliance.” Radical reliance means that the adherent would receive no medical care under any circumstance, even an emergency.

Today, many Christian Scientists are more moderate, receiving medical care only in emergency cases like a car accident or heart attack. Eddy states that it is acceptable for Christian Scientists to get a bone set. Also, they could freely receive dental and eye care.

However, some radical reliance adherents would go above and beyond Eddy’s allowance. It is fair to wonder about these inconsistencies between medical care indicating a lack of trust in God while dental care is deemed acceptable. Eddy claimed. There are a variety of responses to whether receiving Novocaine when getting a cavity is a moral issue or not. However, taking pain medicine like Advil or ibuprofen would be off-limits to a practicing CSer. Though an eye exam was allowed, as is wearing glasses and contacts, typically receiving cataract surgery is not considered relying on Christian Science. The line between what constitutes relaying on Christian Science or “going the medical route” is increasingly blurry.

Most Christian Science practitioners (vocational Christian Science healers) will not pray for someone receiving medical care. Some Christian Science churches might refuse someone as a member, revoke their membership, or ask a “reader” to resign if they needed regular medical care for a chronic issue. Currently, Christian Science nursing homes do not allow any medical care, even pain medicine, regardless of whether the patient has dementia, heart disease, or cancer.

The CS Board of Directors is increasingly vocal about being tolerant of Christian Scientists receiving medical care. They emphasize that Christian Scientists can choose whether or not to receive medical care.Yet, Christian Scientists believe that the only reason to use medical care is failure at understanding or trusting Christian Science. Often, Christian Scientists receive medical care “at last” after the problem is too advanced to be treated successfully and effectively. Thus, Christian Scientists are not encouraged to receive preventative care or regular check-ups when problems might be caught early on and addressed with minimum care. Medical histories are often unknown or non-existent. As a result, many Christian Scientists are unaware of their family’s medical history.

For more information:

Are Christian Scientsts Free to Choose Medical Care or not (Secular)

Why I left Christian Science (secular) by Louise Kinross

Dying the Christian Science Way by Carolyn Fraser

Released: Walking from Shame and Blame into Wholeness by Paggy Cook

Life after Christian Science: Going to the Doctor by Katie Beim-Esche

Mary Baker Eddy’s Belief in Practice:

It is well documented that Mary Baker Eddy received medical care herself.

The Life of Mary Baker G. Eddy and the History of Christian Science by Willa Cather /Georgine Milmine (secular).

Also, Mary Baker Eddy died a physical death and was buried. You can visit her grave.

Mary Baker Eddy Memorial in Mount Auburn Cemetery

Secret Link