Is Christian Science a sort of sacred “upper room” where the favored few can have innermost knowledge of God (Luke 22:12, Acts 1:13)?  I once thought so—but no more.  I’ve come to see that CS is just another obscure little tent in a nondescript sprawl of tents, quite outside the holy city and on the road to nowhere.

How do the tent-dwellers convince themselves that they’ve found the ultimate spiritual sanctuary? How did they wander away from the city of the King and wind up here in the first place? In digging for answers so I can more effectively help others escape CS, I’ve come across a book that you may find valuable.

It’s called The Challenge of the Cults and New Religions, by researcher, theologian, and apologist Ron Rhodes, ThD, (Zondervan, 2001, 382 pages), and there are two points to be made about the book.

First, its succinct refutation of Mary Baker Eddy’s claim to have received God’s final revelation will be good to have on my shelf. Her textbook, weighing in at 700 pages as the purported “key” to all 1500 pages of the Bible, more than meets its match in Rhodes’s 25-page takedown. The writing is factual, dispassionate, civil, and meticulously documented.  P. P. Quimby, from whom Eddy borrowed many of her ideas, is down for the count.Second, in a broader scope, Rhodes impressively gives us the big picture on the fast-growing reach of spiritual counterfeits today in America and around the world—both what they teach and why they’ve able to make such rapid gains. (This is what I was getting at with the analogy of CS as one little self-important tent in a sprawling landscape of them, all going nowhere.)

In a dozen concise chapters, he covers not only CS and other “mind sciences,” but also Mormonism, Jehovah’s Witnesses, New Age, Scientology, Hindu-based cults, the Unification Church, Baha’i, Unitarian Universalism, Oneness Pentecostalism, Freemasonry—and even Satanism.

Rhodes’s discussion of reasons for the cults’ growth was powerfully convicting to me. Thinking of what I call Jesus’ “green parables” in Matthew 13, we can see in 21st-century culture the “soil conditions” that make for runaway growth of beliefs and lifestyles hostile to the Christian faith. He lists ten in particular, beginning with (1) failures by the church, (2) failures of the family, (3) backlash against secular humanism, and (4) the recent fad for Eastern belief systems.

The list continues with (5) relativistic worldviews, (6) emphasis on the self, and (7) emphasis on feelings and experience. The foregoing trends have been force-fed into the public consciousness by (8) penetration into the fields of business, education, and healthcare and by (9) massive saturation in media—much worse today, due to smartphones and social media, than when Rhodes was writing in the early internet era (2001). Last and most ominous, operating in a vicious feedback loop with all the other factors, he calls out (10) moral rebellion, the satanic lie, “You shall be as gods.”

I came away from reading The Challenge of the Cults with a heightened sense of urgency to do all in my power to help Christian Scientists see through the falsehood of Eddy’s doctrine and find their way home to the family of God.

Obviously, I won’t approach it by urging them to stop following a cult—given the harsh and negative connotations that word carries—but I’m better equipped for the work by realizing, thanks to Rhodes, the clearly cultic signature of CS, both doctrinally with its twisting of biblical truth, and socially with its tyrannical grip on persons’ free will.

Seeing the cultic signature of CS has also helped me break out of the self-condemnation and regret that can tend to obsess the ex-CSer: “How could I have surrendered myself to that, so abjectly for so long?”

The answer is—it’s a trap that can stealthily ensnare any fallen human being at any time in history, and particularly today in our own time when the ten causative factors are surging as Rhodes shows.

Paul has the definitive reply to this unproductive self-reproach: “There has no temptation taken you but such as is common to man. But God is faithful, who will… with the temptation also make a way to escape” (I Cor 10:13).

The powerful apologetics handbook that Ron Rhodes has produced is, I would gratefully assert, part of the escape route that our patient and merciful Father has provided for you and me who were Christian Scientists, and for His lost but not forgotten sheep who still are CSers—but not, we pray, for much longer!

John Andrews was baptized in 1993 after more than 40 years in Christian Science. Residing in Colorado, he is an ordained Presbyterian elder and retired from a career in politics and education. He has written a number of books including Discovering a Larger God and With You Always. Contact: AndrewsJK@aol.com
Secret Link